Every November the same thing happens in group chats and running forums. Someone posts a screenshot of an easy run in 3°C weather, average heart rate 138, and asks why the identical loop in September averaged 148.
The honest answer is that cold weather changes your cardiovascular maths in two opposite directions at once. Depending on how cold it is, how long you're out, and what you're wearing, your heart rate at a given pace can drop, hold steady, or climb. Your watch doesn't know which is happening. It just reports the number.
TL;DR: In the cold, blood vessels near the skin narrow to conserve heat, which pushes more blood into your core. That raises stroke volume, so at a given submaximal pace heart rate is often the same or slightly lower than in mild conditions. But cold also raises blood pressure and sympathetic drive, shivering adds metabolic work, and cold strain degrades performance. So heart rate can move either way, and it stops being a clean proxy for effort. Pace and perceived effort are more reliable in winter, your optical sensor is less reliable on a cold wrist, and your VO2 max estimate can wobble because it's built on a heart-rate-to-pace relationship.
YouTube: Related video
The mechanism: blood moves inward
When cold air hits exposed skin, cutaneous vasoconstriction kicks in. The arterioles feeding your skin narrow, which cuts heat loss at the surface and shifts that blood volume toward your core.
The downstream effects are well described in the cardiovascular literature. Central blood volume rises, so the heart fills more completely and stroke volume increases. In a review of heart rate and blood pressure responses in the cold, Emmett found that in healthy subjects exercising in cold conditions, heart rate was generally lower or no different than in thermoneutral conditions, while stroke volume was higher and cardiac output stayed similar. Systolic pressure tended to be the same or higher.
Read that again, because it's the opposite of the folk belief. For a healthy person doing steady submaximal work, the cold often makes the heart's job more efficient per beat: more volume per contraction, fewer contractions needed.
That's why so many runners see a lower average heart rate on cold easy runs. It's not fitness appearing overnight. It's haemodynamics.
But cold also raises the cost of the work
The picture flips once you add other variables.
Cold exposure drives sympathetic activation. Blood pressure rises, and population data consistently shows blood pressure running higher in colder months. A cross-sectional study of roughly 9,000 adults found outdoor temperature and season were associated with shifts across systolic pressure, diastolic pressure, and pulse pressure, with the pattern differing by sex. A higher afterload means the heart is pushing against more resistance, which is extra cardiac work for the same pace.
Add shivering and you're adding real metabolic demand on top of running. Add heavy clothing and you're carrying more mass and trapping heat unevenly. Add cold-induced diuresis, the well-documented tendency to pee more in the cold, and you can arrive at dehydration faster than you'd expect in weather that doesn't feel sweaty.
And then there's performance itself. A 2025 crossover study put 14 recreationally active adults through four 20-minute treadmill walks at 20°C, 10°C, and 0°C. At 0°C, forearm skin temperature dropped by more than 10°C, and dexterity and grip strength declined. Ten minutes of rewarming at 23°C only partially restored performance. This wasn't a maximal test — it was moderate work in mild-to-cold air — and the body was still measurably worse at doing things.
So the honest summary is: at a given pace, cold often lowers heart rate early through haemodynamics while raising cardiovascular strain through pressure and sympathetic tone. Both are true. That's why your numbers look inconsistent from run to run.
First ten minutes versus forty minutes in
The pattern within a single cold run is usually distinctive.
| Phase | What you'll typically see | Why |
|---|---|---|
| First 5-10 minutes | HR lower than expected for the pace | Vasoconstriction, high central blood volume, high stroke volume |
| 10-25 minutes | HR drifts toward normal, sometimes above | Core temperature rises, vasodilation reverses, layers trap heat |
| 25-45 minutes | Looks similar to mild-weather running, or higher if overdressed | Clothing becomes a heat challenge, dehydration starts to bite |
| Stop and stand around | HR stays elevated longer | Cold + post-exercise blood pressure response |
That middle phase is where winter runs go wrong. People dress for the first two minutes, overheat by minute twenty, sweat through their base layer, then get cold again when they slow down or stop.
The practical version of this: dress for 8-10°C warmer than the actual temperature, and expect to be slightly cold for the first mile. That's correct, not a mistake.
Why your zones feel wrong in November
Heart rate zones are built on a percentage of maximum heart rate. Maximum heart rate barely changes with weather. But the heart rate you achieve at a given pace does, and that's the part the zone model quietly assumes is stable.
Two consequences follow.
Your easy pace may drift out of Zone 2 on the watch while feeling identical. If cold lowers your HR by five or six beats at the same effort, an easy aerobic run that used to sit at the top of Zone 2 now sits in Zone 1. Nothing about your fitness changed. The measurement did.
Your heart rate zones may now be wrong relative to your actual physiology, if you set them from the 220-minus-age formula and never touched them. Winter is a good moment to check: three or four weeks of consistent data usually reveals whether the boundaries match where your easy runs actually live. Here's a fuller guide to setting Apple Watch heart rate zones if yours are still on the default.
The deeper issue is heart rate lag and drift. In cold weather, heart rate tends to respond more slowly at the start of a run, then climb more steeply when you warm up. That combination makes the first ten minutes nearly useless for zone-based pacing. Which is exactly the window most runners use to decide whether the run is going well.
Your watch is also less accurate in the cold
This part gets ignored, and it matters.
Wrist optical sensors work by shining light into the skin and detecting changes in blood volume. Cold skin means less peripheral perfusion, which means a weaker signal, which means more noise. On a cold morning with a loose strap and a sleeve pulled over the watch, you can get readings that are 10-15 beats off, or gaps of several minutes where the watch simply doesn't have a value.
Three fixes that actually help:
- Wear the watch a finger's width above the wrist bone, snug enough that it doesn't slide, with the sensor flat against skin.
- Keep the watch under your sleeve or use a thin glove that covers it, so the skin under the sensor stays warm.
- If you care about accuracy for a session, use a chest strap. Optical sensors are convenient, not precise, and winter is when that gap is widest.
If you consistently see flat stretches or spikes in cold-weather heart rate data, that's a sensor problem before it's a physiology problem.
What this does to your cardio fitness number
Apple Watch estimates VO2 max from the relationship between heart rate and pace during outdoor walks and runs. Because cold shifts that relationship, the estimate can move without your fitness moving.
Two things worth knowing. First, the estimate only updates during qualifying outdoor walks and runs in the Workout app, so a treadmill winter means a flat line — the reason your cardio fitness graph stops moving in January is often just that you moved indoors. More on that in what your VO2 max estimate can and can't tell you.
Second, when the estimate does move in winter, treat a drop of one or two points as weather, not decline. Look at the 90-day trend. A single cold-weather reading is noise.
How to pace winter runs without trusting the number
The technique that works is boring and reliable: pace and effort lead, heart rate confirms.
Use the talk test for easy runs. If you can speak in full sentences with a slight breathlessness, you're in the right place — regardless of what the watch says. Cold can drop your HR enough to make a genuinely hard effort read as Zone 1.
Use pace as your anchor on known routes. If your easy pace is 5:45/km in September and today you're running 5:45/km at 8 bpm lower, you're doing the same physiological work with a different readout. Don't speed up to chase the number.
Give the warm-up 10-15 minutes. Cold muscles, cold airways, and slow heart rate kinetics all argue for a longer progressive start. Most winter injuries and most bad pacing decisions happen in the first mile.
Re-check your effort at minute 25. If you're overheating, shed a layer. If your heart rate has jumped 10 beats and you're still at easy pace, you're probably overdressed, dehydrated, or both.
Drink even when it's cold. Cold-weather thirst is blunted and cold diuresis increases losses. A dry mouth at 2°C is a real signal.
There's a related pattern worth understanding here: the same thing that makes your heart rate climb late in a run in mild weather shows up differently when it's cold. That's heart rate drift, and it's the reason a 60-minute winter run can start in Zone 1 and finish in Zone 3 at the same pace.
Who should be more careful in the cold
Cold weather exercise is safe for most healthy people, but the cardiovascular strain is real, not imagined.
Be more conservative if you have known coronary artery disease, uncontrolled hypertension, or a history of cold-induced chest pain. Cold raises blood pressure and increases cardiac workload, and in people with coronary disease the combination of cold and exercise can reduce myocardial oxygen supply while demand rises. That's a genuine physiological risk, not a liability warning.
Be deliberate if you have exercise-induced asthma or reactive airways. Cold, dry air is a classic trigger for bronchoconstriction. A scarf or a buff over the mouth helps humidify the air, and a longer warm-up reduces the chance of an attack.
Be aware if you have Raynaud's, cold urticaria, or significant peripheral vascular disease. These are comfort and safety issues long before they're fitness issues.
And the universal rule: chest pain, unusual breathlessness, dizziness, or a heart rate that won't come down after you stop are reasons to stop and get checked, not reasons to push through a session.
The reframe for winter training
Winter running is where the gap between what your watch reports and what your body is doing gets widest. The cold doesn't make you fitter or less fit. It changes the readout.
One more practical consequence: if you move your quality sessions indoors for the winter, your outdoor heart-rate comparisons stop being meaningful. A treadmill run at 12°C in a gym is not the same stimulus as a 2°C run outside, and the watch treats them as different contexts for good reason. Keep a note of which sessions were indoors so you don't compare across them by accident.
So use the season for the things that aren't heart-rate dependent: consistent easy volume, strength work, sleep, and keeping your aerobic base intact. When your heart rate looks strange in the cold, assume weather first, sensor second, physiology third, and fitness last.
That's also how the daily health score at Century AI treats winter data: it compares you to your own recent baseline rather than to an absolute target, because a five-beat shift in November is usually the season, not you.
The bottom line
Cold air narrows the vessels near your skin, shifts blood into your core, and increases stroke volume — which is why your heart rate is often lower at the same pace on a cold easy run. At the same time, cold raises blood pressure, adds sympathetic drive, and degrades physical performance, so it can also push your heart rate up.
Your watch can't tell which is happening, and its optical sensor is less reliable on cold skin. Pace, the talk test, and how the run actually felt are better anchors in winter. Look at trends across weeks, not readings on a single cold morning.
Century AI helps you understand your body with a daily health score, recovery score, and sleep insights — using the watch you already wear.
